- By Francis Wheen Ronny Agustinus

Das Kapital: Kisah Sebuah Buku yang Mengubah Dunia

  • Title: Das Kapital: Kisah Sebuah Buku yang Mengubah Dunia
  • Author: Francis Wheen Ronny Agustinus
  • ISBN: 9789791260138
  • Page: 220
  • Format: Paperback
  • Das Kapital Kisah Sebuah Buku yang Mengubah Dunia Menawan dan provokatif membujuk pembaca untuk melihat Das Kapital secara segar Socialist ReviewTak ada buku lain sepanjang sejarah yang sedemikian dipuja sekaligus dikecam selain Das Kapital Analisa t

    Menawan dan provokatif membujuk pembaca untuk melihat Das Kapital secara segar Socialist ReviewTak ada buku lain sepanjang sejarah yang sedemikian dipuja sekaligus dikecam selain Das Kapital Analisa tajam Karl Marx tentang cara kerja kapitalisme ini terus dipelintir, dihujat, disalahkan, bahkan dilarang.Tapi krisis ekonomi global bertubi tubi akhirnya menyadarkan Menawan dan provokatif membujuk pembaca untuk melihat Das Kapital secara segar Socialist ReviewTak ada buku lain sepanjang sejarah yang sedemikian dipuja sekaligus dikecam selain Das Kapital Analisa tajam Karl Marx tentang cara kerja kapitalisme ini terus dipelintir, dihujat, disalahkan, bahkan dilarang.Tapi krisis ekonomi global bertubi tubi akhirnya menyadarkan banyak orang tentang kebenaran analisa Marx Di tengah upaya mencari akar dan soslusi krisis, Presiden Perancis Nicolas Sarkozy terfoto sedang membaca Das Kapital Di Jerman, cetak ulang Das Kapital melejit sebagai buku bestseller Versi manga Das Kapital ludes ribuan eksemplar di Jepang hanya dalam hitungan hari Salah besar untuk mengatakan ajaran Marx sudah tak relevan pada zaman kita.Buku Francis Wheen ini dengan bernas mengupas riwayat Das Kapital proses penyusunan serta pengaruh pengaruh yang melatarinya, tesis tesis dasar serta dampaknya, penerimaan terhadapnya dari saat diterbitkan hingga sekarang, 150 tahun sesudahnya, serta menggarisbawahi pentingnya mempelajari Das Kapital demi mewujudkan sebuah dunia yang lebih adil dan sejahtera bagi banyak orang.

    1 thought on “Das Kapital: Kisah Sebuah Buku yang Mengubah Dunia

    1. "لا أحسب أن أحدًا كتب عن النقود وجيوبه خاوية إلى هذا الحد."كارل ماركسربما تكون جيوب ماركس الخاوية وحالته المادية البائسة طيلة حياته هي ما حرّكت عقله العبقرية لملاحظة النظام الاقتصادي وفضح الرأسمالية وممارساتها الوحشية اللاإنسانية، ووضعها في أهم كتاب في التاريخ البشري وهو " [...]

    2. Η ιστορική διαδρομή του Κεφαλαίου, από τη γέννηση στο μυαλό του Μαρξ, ως την αποδοχή του σύγχρονου του κόσμου κ μέχρι την πραγμάτωση ως φορέα της μεγαλύτερης σύγχρονης επανάστασης. Ο μαρξισμός, δεν ήταν τόσο ιδεολογία όσο διαδικασία κριτικής, συνεχής διαλεκτική επιχειρημα [...]

    3. "ولكن ما هو عدد الأشخاص الذين خطر لهم أن يدرجوا كارل ماركس في قائمة الكتاب والفنانين العظماء؟. والهدف الأساسي لكتابي هذا هو أن يقنع بعض هؤلاء على الأقل بأن يعيدوا النظر." فرانسيس وينكنت قد تابعت محاضرات الدكتور ديفيد هارفي عن كتاب رأس المال/ الجزء الأول وقد رأيت كيف قدم نظرة أ [...]

    4. This is a book about the book that probably directly and indirectly influenced the 20th Century more than any other. While a thin volume (especially when compare to the great work that it explores) it does some valuable work and sets a few important records straight. Perhaps key amongst these is to underscore that Das Kapital cannot and should not be seen as a "Marxist bible of eternally codified canons" - although such a religious cult soon developed around the book, a book which is probably as [...]

    5. Karl Marxin (1818 – 1883) vaikutus modernille maailmalle on ollut suunnaton. Hänen teoksiaan on painettu ja ajatuksiaan levitetty ympäri maailmaa – eniten sitten Jeesuksen. Pitkän 1900-luvun aikana (termi Eric Hobsbawmin) hänen filosofiansa innoitti ns. sosialistista leiriä, jonka alaisuudessa eli parhaimmillaan puolet maailman väestöstä.Marx oli kapitalismina tunnetun talousjärjestelmän suurin kriitikko. Noin 1850-luvun vaihteesta lähtien hän tuotti valtavan määrän erilaista [...]

    6. A lovely small essay on "Das Kapital" not as a classic of political economy, but as a literary effort. However odd it may sound to ferret out elements of Gothic romance in Marx, the metaphors are there, and are quite likely things Karl-Heinrich himself would've understood: the creation (capitalism) that turns on and ensnares its creators, the creation that lives by draining out the life and soul of its creator. Wheen is having a good time here, but he's serious enough about "Kapital" as more tha [...]

    7. I picked this up because I read a review that pointed out the similarity of Das Kapital to a gothic novel. I've never read, nor likely ever will read, Das Kapital(especially not in a coffee shop where an odd little man will keep trying to make eye contact with me until I acknowledge him so that he can talk about Marx) but this slim, engaging work has at least provided me with enough of an idea of the work to be able to discuss it with at least a modicum of intelligence. And, if I prove to be as [...]

    8. #DasKapital adalah karya fragmenter yang tak lengkap. Marx sendiri merancang 6 jilid, sedangkan yang terbit semasa hidupnya hanya jilid pertama. Jilid ke-2 dan ke-3 adalah hasil kompilasi Engels. Maka ini penting diketahui terutamanya oleh penganut komunisme yang berkeras bahawa apa yang diucap Marx benar, dan yang tidak diucapnya salah.Kata ekonomis Michael Lebowitz, benar bahawa Marx dengan bijaksana telah menemukan satu benua baru, tapi itu tidak berarti Marx telah memetakan benua itu semuany [...]

    9. في ثلاث فصول يلخص الكتاب حياة كتاب "رأس المال- كارل ماركس" . يبدأ الكاتب بحياة ماركس الصحفية و معاناته في المنفى. ثم يبدأ بوصف المعاناة التي ساهمت في مولد الفكرة لدى ماركس. ثم ينتقل من ذلك الى مراحل كتابة الكتاب و التقسيم الاول لكتابه. و يختتمه بردود الفعل بعد ظهور المجلد الاول [...]

    10. رأس المال لكارل ماركس – سيرة يتناول هذا الكتاب المثير، قصة الكتاب الاقتصادي الأشهر، وحكاية مؤلفه الذي تحول اسمه في فترة من الزمن إلى مفردة حياتية يومية، وتحولت نظريته إلى دستور لعدد كبير من الدول، بل إنها حددت العالم إلى التقسيم الشهير والذائع حتى الآن، العالم الأول الرأسم [...]

    11. Wheen's brief, enthusiastic treatment of one of the Western canon's most forbidding volumes doesn't exactly make you want to read it, but does generate new respect for its eccentricity and prophetic power. Early on, Wheen argues that Das Kapital should be seen as a work of art, and not as a mind-numbing economics text:"By the time he wrote Das Kapital, he was pushing out beyond conventional prose into radical literary collage -- juxtaposing voices and quotations from mythology and literature, fr [...]

    12. Very engrossing and well written. And just as the reviewer Bill Ward said, "Wheen shows that Marx's work is something like a vast Gothic novel, whose heroes are enslaved by the monster they created: capitalism." I can't believe I'm saying this but after reading this, I want to read Capital from cover to cover.This small book is broken down into only three chapters in which the author describes some biographical history about Marx and the circumstances of his life leading up to the first submissi [...]

    13. Really, a person with any sense of history has to read Capital. It's a vitally important work to understanding economy from the 19th century forward. But why not, before plunging into what Wheen describes as a gothic horror novel without reading a history of Capital's history? So glad I did. His enthusiasm for Capital is infectious and makes the reader EXCITED to have at Marx's classic. I also took his suggestion and purchased McLellan's abridgment of Capital. While one day I'd love to read all [...]

    14. إيه بقى اللى أنا قريته دا :Dكتاب نظرى بمفاهيم ومصطلحات لمحبى الاقتصاد مع ذكر مشاهد من حياة كارل ماركس و ظروفه المعيشية و كيفية كتابته لما سمى بعد فكريْا (( الماركسية )) لا يفضل قراءته كتلخيص لمنهجية كارل ماركس و تفكيره

    15. يجيب هذا الكتاب على سؤال شغل الناس كيف خرج الكتاب العظيم رأس المال ؟ ستجد ضمن فصول الكتاب سرد جميل لمرحلة مخاض رأس المال وكيف أنه انتظر سنوات طويلة حتى يخرج بشكل كامل .

    16. Interesting to find out that Marx intended Das Kapital to be a literary work much like Pound's Cantos incorporating disjunctive methods! Maybe a way in for me.

    17. The book is split into 4 parts: Introduction, Gestation, Birth, and Afterlife. Under Introduction and Gestation, the book gives an account of the journey Marx has been through leading to the publication of his magnum opus - Das Kapital. In Birth, the book looks at several concepts espoused by Marx in Das Kapital. Lastly, in Afterlife, the book explores how different people looked upon, interpreted, and used, Das Kapital - in the years and decades since its released. Personally, I find the book t [...]

    18. Como o livro "Das Kapital" foi escrito: as dúvidas, as doenças do autor e na família, os problemas, as dívidas, a pobreza, a pressão dos editores, os rascunhos ilegíveis, Acrescente-se a isso as críticas, os comentários e as comparações feitas por outros autores.Trata-se de um guia para inserir o leitor nos aspectos psicológicos e a ambientação em que a obra foi redigida. Da mesma forma, não serve como uma introdução à "opus", tão somente com referências leves e não aprofunda [...]

    19. Nopealukuinen ja olennaisen Karl Marxista ja Pääoman kirjoitushistoriasta tiivistävä, hyvin kirjoitettu ja monipuolinen kirja. Pääoman kaunokirjallisten elementtien esittely oli hyvin kiinnostava katsaus.

    20. Kao što i naslov kaže, knjiga o tome kako je Marks pisao Kaptal. O njegovom životu u to vreme, problemima, i na kraju o uticaju knjige. Čitko, ne suvoparno i ne preopširno pisano.

    21. I had to read Das Kapital when I was studying political science for my undergrad degree. That was during the Cold War, and so politics was of course colored by Soviet/American relations, so it was necessary to understand communism and socialism in order to understand the politics of the time. I liked Das Kapital and The Communist Manifesto, and I understood them when I read them. This book gave me much more insight into Karl Marx and told me the story of what the man went through when he was try [...]

    22. I really like the case that Francis Wheen makes in this brief, entertaining, ever so slightly ironic, and engaging discussion of Capital that Marx might just becme the most important thinker in the 21st century. Alas, the downside is that this may be the case precisely because his work has lost its political threat, at least in the context of the collapse of Actually Existing Socialism.Capital is perhaps the most important book about capitalism that there is, in part because it is always the cri [...]

    23. Having read Das Kapital in college as part of my studies in Economic History I was intrigued when I came upon this title. What in this very short book could Mr. Wheen say about Karl Marx's massive tome? Surprisingly, he can and does say a lot about the genesis of Marx's work as well as its meaning and, most importantly, its impact. I remember my economic studies as having focused on the economic theories propounded by Marx and having been impressed that he shared with Adam Smith the subsequently [...]

    24. This little book reads easily and brilliantly, and is especially interesting to those with Leftist sympathies. Beyond that, Wheen provides the space (although 'tainted', so to say, by unconditional admiration for Marx) for moderate critics of Das Kapital to redimension the place they have assigned to Marx. For an aspiring Das Kapital reader, this book provides the right setting to semi-arbitrarily make one feel as if one is reading fiction, which makes Marx all the easier to enjoy. Most contempo [...]

    25. A very engaging and thought-provoking precis of Das Kapital and its importance; this book gave background to the creation, a summary of the content, and a short history of the influence of this monumental work.I quite enjoyed the generous spirit with which Mr Wheen approached Marx's opus--in the hands of a more mean-spirited or shallow dogmatist, this might have been a railing against the Hegelian dialectic in which it is cast, or a spotlighting of supposed unfulfilled prophecies and promise. In [...]

    26. Kita mengenal paradigma penelitian kualitatif yang mengajarkan metode observasi parsitipatoris untuk mendapatkan tesis yang mantap mengenai satu objek yang sifatnya kompleks, seperti budaya. Hal inilah yang tidak didapatkan Marx ketika harus melakukan kritik tajam terhadap kegagalan Kapitalisme yang menyentuh semua aspek kehidupan manusia modern. Setidaknya, itulah yang bisa saya dapatkan dari buku ini. Betapa Marx menghabiskan waktu sekian lama dengan penelusuran literatur (di museum dan perpus [...]

    27. This book is a decent short account of Marx's struggle to write the first three books of Das Kapital. Despite its short length, it manages to ramble a bit, and doesn't do that great a job explaining the basic principles of Marxism or the milestones of Marx's life.Marx in fact only completed one book, and his friend Engels completed the next two. The three volumes make up a work almost unreadable due to its length and density.Wheen explains labor and labor power as employees getting paid for valu [...]

    28. The author's approach is intriguing: he explores Das Kapital through the lens of literary criticism. In Kapital Marx's task is to show this unreal thing: capital, and the very real material effects it has on the lives and environment. For this task he looks to various literary models, such as Jonathon Swift's Gulliver's travels, and the gothic novels with their emphasis on the spectres and the horrors they create. This is why you encounter such difficult theorizing such as C-M-C and M-C-M, (or C [...]

    29. Das Kapital is a book about economics that changed the world; but is it art? Wheen shows how Marx created a cross between a Gothic novel and a Greek tragedy where capitalism eats its children, vampire-like, where commodities take on a life of their own like his beloved novel Frankenstein, where Dickinsinian irony is punctuated by grim stats and stories of exploitation and misery. Blending economics, philosophy, and anthropology, Wheen calls it “entirely sui generis.” Though Marx researched i [...]

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *